Skip to content
SlabScore
Guides
← Guides

What a 10, a 9 and an 8 look like

Nobody can tell you what grade your card will get — not us, and not a grader until it is in their hands. What you can do is look at it the way they do, then pick the grade you would bet on.

The four things a grader checks

  • Centering — how even the borders are. Compare the thinner border with the thicker one, side to side and top to bottom, front and back. 55/45 means the thinner side is 45% of the two together.
  • Corners — four sharp points, or any rounding, fraying, or a white dot where the ink has worn off.
  • Edges — clean lines, or nicks and white chipping along the sides. They show most on the back.
  • Surface — scratches, print lines, dents, or a dull patch where the gloss is gone. Tilt the card under a light.

PSA

GradeFront centeringBack centeringWhat else it allows
PSA 10 Gem Mintabout 55/45 or better75/25 or betterNothing you would notice: four sharp corners, full gloss, no staining. A slight print flaw only if it does not hurt the look.
PSA 9 Mintabout 60/40 or better90/10 or betterOne small flaw — a faint wax stain on the back, a minor print spot, or slightly off-white borders.
PSA 8 NM-MTabout 65/35 or better90/10 or betterLooks like a 9 at a glance. Up close: the slightest fraying at one or two corners, or a few of the 9’s small flaws.
  • PSA 10 Gem Mint

    Front centering
    about 55/45 or better
    Back centering
    75/25 or better
    What else it allows
    Nothing you would notice: four sharp corners, full gloss, no staining. A slight print flaw only if it does not hurt the look.
  • PSA 9 Mint

    Front centering
    about 60/40 or better
    Back centering
    90/10 or better
    What else it allows
    One small flaw — a faint wax stain on the back, a minor print spot, or slightly off-white borders.
  • PSA 8 NM-MT

    Front centering
    about 65/35 or better
    Back centering
    90/10 or better
    What else it allows
    Looks like a 9 at a glance. Up close: the slightest fraying at one or two corners, or a few of the 9’s small flaws.

PSA can allow a little more off-centre when the card looks great otherwise — that call is the grader’s.

Read from psacard.com on 13 November 2026.

TAG

TAG gives every card a number out of 1,000 and the grade follows from that number, so two 10s can sit 40 points apart. Its backs are measured separately for trading cards.

GradeFront centeringBack centering (trading cards)What else it allows
TAG 10 Pristine (990–1,000)about 51/49about 52/48Corners and edges with no visible wear; a surface whose only flaws a person could not see.
TAG 10 Gem Mint (950–989)about 55/45about 65/35Four sharp corners; at most a very small pit, a light scratch that stays in the gloss, or a faint print line.
TAG 9 Mint (900–949)about 60/40about 75/25Corners still sharp, with up to two very light touches on the front; a few small pits or a longer light scratch.
TAG 8 NM-MT (800–849)about 65/35about 95/5One corner may show minor wear; light wear and small chips along the edges; a minor roller line may show.
  • TAG 10 Pristine (990–1,000)

    Front centering
    about 51/49
    Back centering (trading cards)
    about 52/48
    What else it allows
    Corners and edges with no visible wear; a surface whose only flaws a person could not see.
  • TAG 10 Gem Mint (950–989)

    Front centering
    about 55/45
    Back centering (trading cards)
    about 65/35
    What else it allows
    Four sharp corners; at most a very small pit, a light scratch that stays in the gloss, or a faint print line.
  • TAG 9 Mint (900–949)

    Front centering
    about 60/40
    Back centering (trading cards)
    about 75/25
    What else it allows
    Corners still sharp, with up to two very light touches on the front; a few small pits or a longer light scratch.
  • TAG 8 NM-MT (800–849)

    Front centering
    about 65/35
    Back centering (trading cards)
    about 95/5
    What else it allows
    One corner may show minor wear; light wear and small chips along the edges; a minor roller line may show.

Read from taggrading.com on 13 November 2026.

CGC

GradeFront centeringBack centeringWhat else it allows
CGC 10 Pristine50/50not publishedFlawless to the eye, with flawless colour and registration. It gets its own label.
CGC 10 Gem Mintabout 55/45 or better75/25 or betterCorners perfect to the eye; no print spots; perfect gloss.
CGC 9 Mintnot published for trading cardsnot published for trading cardsFour sharp corners with only minor wear; slight edge flaws; original gloss, with a few specks or one small spot.
CGC 8 NM/Mintnot published for trading cardsnot published for trading cardsFairly smooth edges with only light wear, plus one very minor flaw — corners that look sharp but are not under a loupe, or a few small print spots.
  • CGC 10 Pristine

    Front centering
    50/50
    Back centering
    not published
    What else it allows
    Flawless to the eye, with flawless colour and registration. It gets its own label.
  • CGC 10 Gem Mint

    Front centering
    about 55/45 or better
    Back centering
    75/25 or better
    What else it allows
    Corners perfect to the eye; no print spots; perfect gloss.
  • CGC 9 Mint

    Front centering
    not published for trading cards
    Back centering
    not published for trading cards
    What else it allows
    Four sharp corners with only minor wear; slight edge flaws; original gloss, with a few specks or one small spot.
  • CGC 8 NM/Mint

    Front centering
    not published for trading cards
    Back centering
    not published for trading cards
    What else it allows
    Fairly smooth edges with only light wear, plus one very minor flaw — corners that look sharp but are not under a loupe, or a few small print spots.

CGC publishes centring for its 9 and 8 on sports cards only (60/40 and 65/35 on the front); for Pokémon and other trading cards it describes the flaws instead. Between 10 and 9 sits a 9.5, Mint+, for a 9 with outstanding eye appeal.

Read from cgccards.com on 13 November 2026.

BGS (Beckett)

BGS grades in half steps and prints four subgrades on the label — centering, corners, edges, surface — and the overall grade leans on the lowest of them, so one weak corner holds the whole card back. Its top grades are Pristine 10, Gem Mint 9.5 and Mint 9; a Black Label is a Pristine 10 with all four subgrades at 10. Beckett’s own centring figures are on its grading scale page, beckett.com/grading.

ACE

ACE grades in whole steps and measures centring by machine on all four sides, front and back.

GradeFront centeringBack centeringWhat else it allows
ACE 10 Gem Mintbetter than 60/40— (one figure for the card)Four undamaged corners, sharp edges, a clean surface; tiny flaws only if they do not spoil the look.
ACE 9 Mint65/35 or better70/30 or betterAlmost a 10, with one small flaw in the corners, edges or surface.
ACE 8 NM-MT70/30 or better75/25 or betterLike a 9, with a few small flaws such as whitening on corners or edges.
  • ACE 10 Gem Mint

    Front centering
    better than 60/40
    Back centering
    — (one figure for the card)
    What else it allows
    Four undamaged corners, sharp edges, a clean surface; tiny flaws only if they do not spoil the look.
  • ACE 9 Mint

    Front centering
    65/35 or better
    Back centering
    70/30 or better
    What else it allows
    Almost a 10, with one small flaw in the corners, edges or surface.
  • ACE 8 NM-MT

    Front centering
    70/30 or better
    Back centering
    75/25 or better
    What else it allows
    Like a 9, with a few small flaws such as whitening on corners or edges.

Read from acegrading.com on 13 November 2026.

Not sure between two?

The grade list next to the question shows what each grade sells for, so you can see what happens if it comes back one lower before you decide.